Cop31 live: diplomats race to compromise on fossil fuels as Cop teeters on brink of failure | Cop31

Cop31 live: diplomats race to compromise on fossil fuels as Cop teeters on brink of failure | Cop31

The Gethsemane
26 Min Read

Day 13 of Cop31 – recapped

That’s all for today – we hope everyone following from Antalya gets a good night’s sleep. Here are the highlights from the 13th day of the 31st UN climate summit, which is still not over:

  • Activists told the Presidency this summit could be one of the ‘most disappointing Cops’ ever

  • Carbon removal must ‘be additional, not a substitute’ for phasing out fossil fuels, a top scientist said

  • ‘We will not allow obstruction to dampen our resolve,’ Tuvalu’s climate minister said

  • The EU was thought to have the backing of 130 countries to get fossil fuels back into the draft text

  • Diplomats raced to find compromise as the joint presidencies held meetings with scores of countries

  • A plenary session gavelled through a handful of less controversial decisions, but the Presidency pushed the big day till Sunday

  • Cop31 President, Murat Kurum, ended the day by announcing a new draft would be with delegates “shortly”, ahead of a new plenary at 9am local time.

Thanks for following – stay tuned for more.

Share

Key events

Murat Kurum, Cop31 President, at a late-night plenary session. Photograph: Khalil Hamra/AP

“Today we have listened to you and sought to find common ground for your expectations,” said Murat Kurum, thanking the tired delegates for their “constructive approach”.

He said the third and final version of the cover decision will be “in your hands shortly”, and parties will have until 6am local time to consider the text, before plenary reconvenes at 9am. The text is currently being scrutinised by the lawyers of the secretariat, he said.

“The political will needed to complete this bridge is present in this room,” he said, declaring the end of the meeting.

Share

Updated at 

Cop31 President, Murat Kurum, has arrived on the main stage, and has been immediately swarmed by delegates. The Turkish-Australian joint presidency has kept a low public profile today, on the first day of overtime, and the transparency they promised has been somewhat hard to come by for observers of the process. Still, as my colleagues have reported on this blog, they have been busy trying to find compromise between different parties.

Share

A handful of less controversial topics have indeed gone through without issue, and the session is taking a brief break before the Cop31 President arrives.

Share

A dispute has broken about gender – and how it is defined – with interventions from Argentina and Paraguay. The draft document “encourages” a finance committee to enhance efforts to ensure gender-responsiveness in implementing its workplan, and requests Parties to consider gender balance and geographical representation when nominating members.

This is not the first time the issue of gender has cropped up in climate negotiations. In previous years, a handful of countries have voiced objections to gender definitions that do not refer to biological sex.

Share

Updated at 

Next up is a text on long-term climate finance, which has been rejected by the African Group. “This process did not provide sufficient space for negotiations,” said the negotiator for Ghana, speaking on the group’s behalf. “For now, it is not ready on our side for adoption.”

The objection is to paragraph 3, which “notes with appreciation” a report on progress towards (belatedly) achieving the goal of mobilising $100bn per year to address the needs of developing countries “in the context of meaningful mitigation actions and transparency on implementation”.

The EU, right after Ghana’s intervention, has said it “cannot accept changes to the text as we have already shown significant flexibility”.

This does not seem to be the smooth ride we were hoping. The chair has just proposed we come back to the decision later in the meeting.

Share

Updated at 

The plenary session has now actually begun, and we understood that it’s only the uncontroversial topics that are to be gaveled through. However, the very first topic, on climate empowerment – helping all members of society engage in climate action – has been met with an immediate objection from Russia that has drawn consternation from other countries. The EU, echoed immediately by the UK, next expressed “surprise and disappointment” at the objection. Panama, speaking on behalf of AILEC – 8 Latin American and Caribbean countries – echoed this.

On account of the objection, the chair has requested the SBI consider the decision at its next session.

Share

Updated at 

Fiona Harvey

The Guardian has been leaked a submission that the countries calling themselves the “progressive coalition” – including the EU, UK and island and developing countries – want added to the cover text that is expected to be brought to a plenary at some point in the hours ahead.

It is an eleventh-hour bid to bolster the language on dealing with overshoot past the Paris agreement goal of limiting heating to 1.5C above preindustrial levels, which is a key demand of the Alliance of Small Island States and other vulnerable nations.

In full UN climate summit language, it reads:

“Also decides to hold 2 high-level dialogues, each one at the ninth and tenth session of the [Conference of the Parties serving as the meeting of the Parties to the Paris Agreement] focused on scientific findings around 1.5 C overshoot, its implications, and the complementarity between equity, science and sustainable development and the urgency of action and support, and further requests the Chair of the Subsidiary Body of Scientific and Technological Advice to prepare, with the support of the Secretariat, a report upon the conclusion of the dialogues for presentation at the Research Dialogue held in conjunction with the subsequent SBSTA session.”

The coalition is also demanding the deletion of language on the use of “carbon capture utilisation and storage technology”

Share

The plenary has been pushed back by half an hour, into Sunday morning local time.

Many diplomats have gone home, eager to get some rest before the (assumed) progress at the morning plenary session. Others are taking rest where they can find it.

A personal sleeping on a sofa at the end of Cop31. Photograph: Murad Sezer/Reuters
Share

The plenary session has just begun. A few weary-looking delegates have started to file in but the main stage has not yet been occupied …

Share
Graham Readfearn

Graham Readfearn

Neither of these things are necessarily anything to brag about, but is Cop31 about to go down as both the biggest and the longest Cop in history?

It is just after 11pm here in Antalya and we have been told that a plenary will commence at 11:30pm but that this will only deal with procedural issues.

We are also getting information from multiple sources that a plenary to come to a final agreement will be planned for 9am. But if previous experience is anything to go by, this could slide.

Earlier tonight, several large negotiating blocs entered the Turkey and Australia joint presidency offices to ask that a reference to a “transition away from fossil fuels” be included in any final agreement here. They also wanted to re-state a previously agreed commitment to triple finance for climate adaptation.

It seems there will be some early hours negotiating still to be done.

The longest Cop in history was Cop25 in 2019 in Madrid which finished early on the Sunday afternoon.

Nobody will want Antalya to beat that. But it might.

Share

Why does it matter if the Cop31 deal neglects to mention fossil fuels? Here’s a quick recap. The main purpose of these annual UN climate summits is to stop the planet from heating. When world leaders signed the Paris agreement at a Cop in 2015, they bound their countries to keeping global heating by the end of the century “well below 2C” above preindustrial levels, and to “pursue efforts” to keep it at 1.5C. We are now at an alarming 1.4C and on track for a ruinous 2.8C.

All of the warming we have experienced so far is the result of human activity, and most of it comes from burning coal, oil and gas (the destruction of nature makes up most of the rest). These three fuels are the backbone of the dirty energy system on which the global economy runs.

Workers assembling equipment around an oil drilling rig at an oilfield in Venezuela on Monday. Photograph: Ariana Cubillos/AP

How fast do we need to kick our addiction to them? A recent report by the UN Environment Programme shows that by 2050 we should be using at least 90% less coal, 65% less oil, and 75% less gas than in 2025. That is just 25 years away to upend everything – and governments around the world are still enthusiastically granting licences to mine more coal, drill more oil and pump more gas. Petrostates such as Saudi Arabia have put up the greatest resistance to the inclusion of “fossil fuels” in Cop texts, but they are by no means the only polluters expanding the production of dirty fuels. And to make matters worse, the money that rich countries promised poor ones to help them transition has not materialised at anywhere near the levels needed – and many of their pledges to cut emissions are conditional on getting that cash.

Share

Updated at 

Three of the world’s biggest carbon polluters agreed to boost oil production this week, during talks in China that appear to have been far more fruitful than the climate summit is shaping up to be.

The fuel deal between the US, China and Russia was struck on Thursday in Shenzhen, China, just as diplomats attending Cop31 were lamenting the removal of fossil fuels from the draft text.

Earlier today, Matt Webb, a diplomacy expert at climate thinktank E3G, described it as “another symptom of the global crisis driven by our continued dependence on volatile fossil fuels”.

“With US refineries maxed out at 95% to 96% utilisation, Washington is essentially asking Beijing to mobilise its estimated 4.8 to 5.1m barrels per day of spare capacity to offset the strait of Hormuz shock – a conflict that cut global supply by 16.1m barrels per day at its peak and which the IEA’s World Energy Outlook 2026 calls the largest energy supply shock in history,” said Webb. “One would question why China, as the world leader in clean energy technology, would want to take this approach. Rather than doubling down on fragile, geopolitically vulnerable supply chains, Cop31 must accelerate the transition to clean energy – the only lasting insulation against fossil fuel volatility.”

Share

A predicament “that never should have deteriorated so far” is how Jasper Inventor, head of the Greenpeace’s delegation, has described the current situation at Cop31, as weary delegates bemoan the lack of a new draft deal or clarity over the next steps.

“The fact that no text has been distributed and no actual negotiations between parties has been happening throughout the day is a predicament, and the situation should never have deteriorated so far,” he said. “Parties need to be sitting across the table, looking each other in the eye and negotiating the text themselves, not waiting behind closed doors for the Presidency to produce a compromise.”

Cop31 President Murat Kurum speaking to journalists. Photograph: Murad Sezer/Reuters

He added: “The climate crisis is accelerating beyond the negotiating rooms here in Antalya and yet we are still waiting for a text that aims to address the root cause of the crisis – ending fossil fuels.”

Share

Updated at 

What if too many people go home? Giuliana Viglione, associate editor at Carbon Brief, has explored the prospect of Cop31 being suspended if too many delegates leave to catch flights back to their countries.

A participant pulling his luggage towards the exit gate during the first overtime day of Cop31. Photograph: Chris McGrath/Getty Images

double quotation markIf and when delegations start departing the country, the Cop may be in danger of losing quorum.

According to the UNFCCC’s draft rules of procedure, two-thirds of parties must be present in order for decisions to be made. (The US is technically still a party to the convention, so this means 132 out of 198 parties to the UNFCCC – and 130 out of 194 parties to the Paris Agreement.)

A loss of quorum would mean a suspension of the talks, which would have to be resumed at a later date.

Share

Updated at 

Fiona Harvey

Fiona Harvey

While we wait for more from the presidencies, here is an interesting sidelight on this year’s Cop. Panama’s environment minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, has been one of the stars of Antalya. His blistering attack on the state of negotiations on Wednesday became a rallying call for “climate-progressive” countries and groups.

The world was “being held hostage by the petroleum mafia”, he told a press conference for the Fossil Fuel Anti-Proliferation Treaty Initiative. “We are in love with our kidnappers. We love the petroleum guys. We can’t live without them, and they are so smart they have convinced us that they are doing this for our own good.”

Panama’s environment minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, speaking to journalists at Cop31. Photograph: Mehmet Emin Menguarslan/Anadolu/Getty Images

But in another set of vital climate-related negotiations, Panama has been playing a markedly different role.

At the International Maritime Organisation, countries are working on a potential levy on the carbon dioxide emitted from international shipping. This levy has been more than a decade in development, as shipping companies and countries reliant on maritime transport have been reluctant for many years to address the 2-3% of global emissions contributed by the industry.

Two years ago, it looked as if green voices had finally won out – IMO members had agreed a framework for cutting their emissions, and a levy on carbon dioxide emissions to help it along. Money raised by the levy – which could amount to tens of billions of dollars a year – could go to help clean up shipping, but some could be diverted to help the most vulnerable countries recover from the impacts of climate catastrophe.

Then came Donald Trump. The US president was bitterly opposed, and members of his administration started a campaign to halt the levy. Some IMO participants described being bullied by the US, while others were threatened with US visa revocation if they did not back down and change their positions.

The campaign worked: at a meeting of the IMO, enough members switched their position to allow for a postponement of the levy.

Next week, at crunch meetings at the IMO headquarters in London, the talks will resume, with a further delay possible. And this time, Panama is on the side of the delayers.

Tristan Smith, professor of energy and transport at University College London, told the Guardian: “Panama’s position moved from supporting the progressive solutions – the levy and the net zero framework [to cut shipping emissions] – in the first half of 2025, to leading the discussion on the weakest alternative to the net zero framework in the first half of 2026.”

Analysis by Smith showed that Panama’s proposals would have produced higher greenhouse gas emissions than alternative plans on the table. Another group of shipping experts told the Guardian they believed there was a “major disconnect” between Panama’s environment ministry and its Maritime and Canal Authority.

As a result, the good work done for the climate at Cop could be undone at the IMO negotiations next week, if shipping interests win out over those who want to cut shipping’s emissions and use a carbon levy to help poor countries stricken by climate disaster.

John Maggs, Coordinator and Accredited Representative to the IMO for the Clean Shipping Coalition, said: “We just hope that the Panamanian delegation that turns up at IMO next week takes heed of what their Environment Ministry is saying and supports adoption of the NZF [Net-Zero Framework].”

The Panama delegation at Cop31 was contacted for comment.

Share

The Cop31 negotiations are an “insult” to people already suffering because of climate breakdown, campaigners have said.

“This must be the last time we allow fossil fuel interests, which are profiting so handsomely from the climate crisis, to hold us to ransom,” said Nick Dearden, director of Global Justice Now, a campaign group. “It is abundantly clear by now that we will not be able to combat climate change as long as those who control the global economy can make money from coal, oil and gas.

The group is calling for a “coalition of the willing” to come together at the second summit to transition away from fossil fuels, which will be co-hosted by Tuvalu and Ireland in 2027.

He added: “After people have experienced the impact of climate change so concretely this summer, it is an insult that a summit supposed to address climate change is struggling to even mention fossil fuels.”

Share

Diplomats race to compromise, a full day after the scheduled end

Fiona Harvey

Fiona Harvey

After all the running down corridors, here is where we are:

After marching into the offices of the joint presidencies en masse and with “the whole world” as one participant put it, at about 6.10pm this evening in Turkey, the EU stayed in the meeting with the joint presidencies only briefly, leaving at about 6.30pm, while many developing countries and the UK stayed in.

The UK and the Alliance of Small Island States (AOSIS) countries remained in the meeting with the presidencies for nearly an hour.

The Guardian understands that the EU left because it needed to have a coordination meeting with its member states and the high ambition coalition, to discuss its way forward.

The issue for the EU is the text under consideration. One possible version would include a reference to the UAE consensus decision at Cop28, paragraph 28 of which contained the key resolution to “transition away from fossil fuels”. This oblique reference to the phaseout of fossil fuels was also the formulation used last year at Belem.

The Guardian understands that such an oblique reference would be acceptable to the High Ambition Coalition, which comprises many developing countries, the UK and some other allies, but there is still a question mark over whether the EU member states will agree to it, or demand something stronger and more explicit.

The EU is now consulting on that.

The Guardian also understands that Saudi Arabia refused to drop its demand for carbon capture and storage (CCS) to be strongly recommended in the text, on a par with the target for electrification, and still refuses to allow any reference to the “transition away from fossil fuels”.

Carbon capture technology at an LNG facility on Barrow Island, Australia, that has consistently underperformed. Photograph: Bloomberg/Getty Images

If this standoff continues and if Saudi continues to hold out on CCS and to refuse any references to fossil fuels, the next step – which the Guardian understands is being actively considered by the EU – could be to force a plenary, at which Saudi Arabia would have to either go along with the consensus or publicly oppose the revised wording.

This is a risky strategy, as Saudi Arabia and its allies could hold out. But Bill Hare, chief executive of the Climate Analytics thinktank, and a longtime observer of Cops, told the Guardian it might be the only strategy left. Some believe the Arab Group is no longer as united behind Saudi Arabia as that country had assumed at the outset of these talks.

“If the overwhelming number of countries here want a strong text, referencing the transition away from fossil fuels and so on, and Saudi Arabia is on its own, I think Saudi Arabia will probably not stand against the global consensus,” Hare said.

The three key demands of the countries calling themselves the progressive coalition are now: a reference to the transition away from fossil fuels, or to the UAE Consensus decision in which that resolution appeared; for stronger wording on the tripling of adaptation finance for developing countries; and for any reference to CCS to be either removed or to be weakened and “balanced” by strong language on electrification.

The Guardian also understands that China and India, though not allied with the EU, the UK and the High Ambition Coalition and their allies, who number about 130 countries, are unlikely to stand against those countries.

Share

Updated at 

Share This Article
Leave a Comment